Dry food carried about 3 times the lead of wet or air-dried food
Dry kibble contained about 3 times as much lead as wet or air-dried food after accounting for calories, and that difference held after the researchers considered the protein source. Unlike mercury, lead was not linked to any type of protein, and the report suggests the format of the food may play a role.
Each added plant ingredient raised glyphosate levels by about 40%
Glyphosate, the widely used herbicide, was detected in 37% of products, and its breakdown product, aminomethylphosphonic acid, in 12%. Each additional plant ingredient that appeared in the first 10 ingredients on a label was associated with approximately 40% more glyphosate. Still, the number of plant ingredients mattered more than where they appeared on the list, Clean Label Project noted.
A plasticizer was the most common contaminant after heavy metals
Di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate (DEHP), a phthalate linked to hormone disruption, appeared in 48 products. Detection rates were similar across formats, but canned and pouched foods that contained it carried about 5 times as much as bagged products, which the authors say may reflect contact with packaging. Acrylamide was measurable in 4 products and was present at trace levels in 24 more foods. Bisphenols, once common in can linings, were nearly absent. Bisphenol A appeared in 2 products and bisphenol S in 1.
In 35 foods, the first ingredient did not reflect most of the recipe
In 35 of the 100 products, the first-listed ingredient was usually a meat or fish, but most of the first 10 ingredients came from a different category, most often plants. In some cases, the same plant ingredient appeared in several forms, such as pea protein and pea flour. The practice, known in the industry as ingredient splitting, is legal. Foods in which plant ingredients outnumbered the first-listed meat or fish tended to carry more lead.
The study does not show what levels of these contaminants pose a health risk to cats
The analysis found differences in contaminant levels among the cat foods tested, but it did not assess whether those levels could harm cats. Clean Label Project states that its results show how products compare with one another, rather than whether a specific product contains enough of a contaminant to cause illness.
The organization also questions whether existing maximum tolerable levels for contaminants in animal feed are appropriate for cats. The organization points to maximum tolerable levels published by the National Research Council and the Association of American Feed Control Officials, which it says were “derived to prevent acute poisoning in livestock, not to protect a housecat eating the same food every day for 15 years.”1
The report notes that chronic exposure to lead, cadmium, mercury, glyphosate, and DEHP has been linked to health effects in mammals, including cancer, brain damage, and reproductive harm.
However, the analysis did not examine those health effects in cats or determine whether the contaminant levels it measured were associated with them.
The findings also have limitations when it comes to individual products. Each product was represented by a single batch, so the analysis does not show how contaminant levels might vary between batches of the same food. Most brands contributed 1 product, and the report limits its brand-level comparisons to brands with at least 3 products tested.
Clean Label Project also operates a certification program. According to the report, its Purity Award, which uses CLP’s own standards, recognizes brands whose products contain lower levels of contaminants, including heavy metals, pesticide residues, and plasticizers, than best-selling products in the same food category. Three brands included in the analysis hold the award.
Not every product tested is a complete diet. At least 3 of the 40 wet foods tested are labeled as complementary foods meant to be fed alongside a complete diet, not as a cat’s only food.
In a statement, the Pet Food Institute (PFI), which represents US pet food manufacturers, criticized Clean Label Project’s analysis, saying it “risks misleading cat owners” because it lacks the scientific and regulatory context needed to interpret its findings.6 PFI emphasized that the analysis evaluates products against a proprietary standard rather than established regulatory standards or science-based risk assessments, and it is unclear whether the research underwent scientific or veterinary review.
Pet food in the US must meet federal and state requirements, and manufacturers use food safety and quality assurance programs that include ingredient specifications, supplier verification, testing protocols, traceability systems, and science-based preventive controls, PFI wrote.6
The report advises rotating proteins and asking brands about testing
The report advises caregivers of cats that eat mostly fish-based food to rotate in other proteins. It also recommends reading past the first ingredient and asking manufacturers whether they test finished products for heavy metals, not just the ingredients that go into them.
“Rotating proteins may help reduce exposure from a single source. This does not mean you need to eliminate fish—some fish-based cat foods met our quality standards,” Clean Label Project wrote.1
Still, the organization said feeding cats a complete diet they will actually eat remains the priority.
References
- Clean Label Project. CLP Insights: cat food category report. 2026. Accessed October 6, 2026. https://cleanlabelproject.org/wp-content/uploads/clean-label-project-cat-food-study-2026.pdf
- American Pet Products Association. Gen Z and cat dads are leading cat ownership's cultural boom: new APPA report reveals what's driving growth in America's feline household. News release. ACCESS Newswire. 2026. Accessed October 6, 2026. https://www.accessnewswire.com/newsroom/en/business-and-professional-services/gen-z-and-cat-dads-are-leading-cat-ownerships-cultural-boom-new-1220581
- Brown CA, Elliott J, Schmiedt CW, Brown SA. Chronic kidney disease in aged cats: clinical features, morphology, and proposed pathogeneses. Vet Pathol. 2016;53(2):309-326. doi:10.1177/0300985815622975
- Royal Veterinary College. Chronic kidney disease in cats explored. May 16, 2019. Accessed October 6, 2026. https://rvc.ac.uk/vetcompass/news/chronic-kidney-disease-in-cats-explored
- Frazier JM. Bioaccumulation of cadmium in marine organisms. Environ Health Perspect. 1979;28:75-79. doi:10.1289/ehp.792875
- Statement from PFI CEO Elise Fennig on Clean Label Project Cat Food Study. Pet Food Institute. October 2, 2026. Accessed October 15, 2026. https://www.petfoodinstitute.org/newsroom/clean-label-statement-cat-food/