• DVM360_Conference_Charlotte,NC_banner
  • ACVCACVC
  • DVM 360
  • Fetch DVM 360Fetch DVM 360
DVM 360
dvm360 | Veterinary News, Veterinarian Insights, Medicine, Pet Care
dvm360 | Veterinary News, Veterinarian Insights, Medicine, Pet Care
By Role
AssociatesOwnersPractice ManagerStudentsTechnicians
Subscriptions
dvm360 Newsletterdvm360 Magazine
News
All News
Association
Breaking News
Education
Equine
FDA
Law & Ethics
Market Trends
Medical
Politics
Products
Recalls
Regulatory
Media
dvm360 LIVE!™
Expert Interviews
The Vet Blast Podcast
Medical World News
Pet Connections
The Dilemma Live
Vet Perspectives™
Weekly Newscast
dvm360 Insights™
Publications
All Publications
dvm360
Firstline
Supplements
Vetted
Clinical
All Clinical
Anesthesia
Animal Welfare
Behavior
Cardiology
CBD in Pets
Dentistry
Dermatology
Diabetes
Emergency & Critical Care
Endocrinology
Equine Medicine
Exotic Animal Medicine
Feline Medicine
Gastroenterology
Imaging
Infectious Diseases
Integrative Medicine
Nutrition
Oncology
Ophthalmology
Orthopedics
Pain Management
Parasitology
Surgery
Toxicology
Urology & Nephrology
Virtual Care
Business
All Business
Business & Personal Finance
Hospital Design
Personnel Management
Practice Finances
Practice Operations
Wellbeing & Lifestyle
Continuing Education
Conferences
Conference Listing
Conference Proceedings
Upcoming dvm360 Conferences
Resources
CBD in Pets
CE Requirements by State
Contests
Partners
Spotlight Series
Team Meeting in a Box
Toolkit
Top Recommended Veterinary Products
Vet to Vet
Veterinary Heroes
  • Contact Us
  • Fetch DVM360 Conference
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Do Not Sell My Information
  • About Us

© 2023 MJH Life Sciences and dvm360 | Veterinary News, Veterinarian Insights, Medicine, Pet Care. All rights reserved.

Advertisement
By Role
  • Associates
  • Owners
  • Practice Manager
  • Students
  • Technicians
Subscriptions
  • dvm360 Newsletter
  • dvm360 Magazine
  • Contact Us
  • Fetch DVM360 Conference
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy
  • Do Not Sell My Information
  • About Us
  • MJHLS Brand Logo

© 2023 MJH Life Sciences™ and dvm360 | Veterinary News, Veterinarian Insights, Medicine, Pet Care. All rights reserved.

Blog: Egg production, pet owner 'fairness' and state freedoms

March 12, 2014
Mark Cushing, JD, Animal Policy Group

Two bills affecting veterinarians may have tanked because of their redundancy.

At about the same time that the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) and United Egg Producers (UEP) announced the end of their ill-fated partnership, U.S. Rep. Jim Matheson (D-Utah) introduced H.R. 4023 in Congress to little fanfare. This bill is the 2014 version of the self-styled Fairness to Pet Owners Act—H.R. 1406 in the last legislative session. So what do we make of this? While neither action on its face had anything to do with the other, in some manner their fates were linked. Let’s explore.

After losing battles in 2011 to impose cage-free standards for egg production in the Oregon and Washington state legislatures, HSUS rose from political ashes and stunned the animal welfare and food animal universe by announcing its alliance with UEP. The two organizations helped introduce federal legislation to impose not cage-free standards but enriched colony standards—standards that closely resembled those HSUS had opposed in the states.

UEP represents the vast majority of large egg producers in the United States, so this marriage of commercial interests with the HSUS political machine seemed formidable, albeit puzzling. Still, it fizzled—this despite the drumbeat from observers repeating that surely this bill would pass if commercial producers and animal rights advocates lobbied arm in arm.

The similar fate encountered by H.R. 1406 and the HSUS-UEP bill may be at least partially explained by the way these bills both attempted to impose one-size-fits-all national standards. Supporters of the bills scoffed at critics who raised the flag of federalism and asserted that states had the freedom to design their own solutions.

But the critics persisted, and one of their sharp observations regarding the Fairness to Pet Owners Act was the idea that, after a century of state regulation of veterinary-client relationships, there was no sound rationale for the federal government to regulate the same thing. Plus, who believed that Congress would stop with this one issue and return authority to the states? Were all features of veterinary-client relationships soon to become the domain of Congress and the Federal Trade Commission?

Advertisement

HSUS and UEP argued that everyone’s interests would be served by imposing a uniform federal standard on how eggs are produced in each state. They derided critics from the federalist camp as self-serving industry advocates, dismissing the rich inventory of state innovations over the years, including Oregon and Washington state egg production legislation in 2011. These critics won the day in no small part because a majority of Congress agreed that there was no compelling reason for Congress to begin regulating the management practices of all farmers in America.

While we await a possible report from the FTC stemming from its October 2012 Workshop on Pet Medications, which may call for uniform national standards as did H.R. 1406, it is highly doubtful that Congress will be any more inclined in 2014 to abandon federalism and state regulation of veterinary-client relationships than it was in 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2013. Rep. Matheson, the new bill’s sponsor, is retiring from Congress and the veterinary profession must be vigilant this year to ensure that his farewell gift does not become this law.

Mark Cushing, JD, is founding partner of the Animal Policy Group, providing government relations and strategic services for various animal health, veterinary and educational interests. He maintains offices in Portland, Ore., and Washington, D.C., and is a frequent speaker at veterinary conferences.

The Veterinary Policy Notes blog on dvm360.com helps veterinarians and other animal health professionals keep abreast of the growing number of issues, political challenges and regulatory initiatives affecting the veterinary profession, animal health industry and animal welfare movement.

Related Content:

RegulatoryBreaking NewsPolitics
Veterinarian kills 2 police officers in Mississippi
Veterinarian kills 2 police officers in Mississippi
FDA conditionally approves Panoquell-CA1 for acute onset of canine pancreatitis
FDA conditionally approves Panoquell-CA1 for acute onset of canine pancreatitis
What you need to know about GFI #256 and the changing landscape of compounding medicine
What you need to know about GFI #256 and the changing landscape of compounding medicine

Advertisement

Latest News

The four-letter word to why you're burning out and feeling unproductive

Merck Manuals recognizes importance of One Health concept

Topical therapy and immunotherapy can save time and frustration with dermatology cases

Texas Tech appoints new faculty member with passion for animal agriculture

View More Latest News
Advertisement